Jay L. Mitchell

January 24, 1956 - October 31, 2023

Facebook

memorial

Buck Creek United Methodist Church

4915 Ferret Street

Buck Creek, IN 47924

765-589-7206 |

Wednesday 11/8, 1:30 pm - 3:00 pm

A Celebration of Life will be held from 1:30 pm until 3:00 pm, Wednesday, November 8, 2023, at Buck Creek United Methodist Church, 4915 Ferret St., Buck Creek. IN 47924.

Memorial contributions in Jay’s name may be given to the Buck Creek United Methodist Church or to the Buck Creek Volunteer Fire Department.

Jay L. Mitchell, 67, of Buck Creek, passed away at his home on Tuesday, October 31, 2023, with his wife, Karen by his side.

He was born January 24, 1956, in Lafayette to the late James E. and E. Marlene (Buck) Mitchell. Jay was a 1974 graduate of William H. Harrison High School. On June 30, 1978, Jay married the love of his life, Karen King, in Buck Creek. Since 2003, Jay and Karen owned and operated Buck Creek Pizza. And Jay coined the motto “We Build Pizzas”. Jay also worked at Rea Magnet Wire in Lafayette for 15 years.

Jay was a volunteer fire fighter on the Washington Township/Buck Creek Fire Department for over 25 years. He loved farming, golfing, and tinkering. He also enjoyed racing cars, riding snowmobiles and Four-Wheeling. Jay was a jack-of-all-trades who had a zest for life. He never stopped, he was always on the move and family members called him the “Energizer Bunny.”

Along with his wife, Karen, he is survived by 2 sisters, Jean (Jon) Randle of Delphi and Judy (Mark) Kettnich of Battle Ground; bonus son, Torry Allen; special cousins, Josh, Patty, and Kristen Buck; several other nieces, nephews, and cousins; and his 2 Bernedoodles, Jack and Jill.

He was preceded in death by his parents, James E. and E. Marlene (Buck) Mitchell and 2 brothers, Jack “Fat Jack” Mitchell and Joe “Porkchop” Mitchell.

Memorial contributions in Jay’s name may be given to Buck Creek United Methodist Church or to the Buck Creek Volunteer Fire Department.

A Celebration of Life will be held from 1:30 pm until 3:00 pm, Wednesday, November 8, 2023, at Buck Creek United Methodist Church, 4915 Ferret St., Buck Creek. IN 47924.

Soller-Baker Funeral Homes, Inc.

Jim Knogge

Mark Gray

Matt and Donna

Bob and Mary Ann Burton

Angela Alderson

Brett and Ronnette Peden

Monica Rennick

Debra Davis

Light a candle

Buck Creek United Methodist Church

4915 Ferret Street

Buck Creek, IN 47924

765-589-7206 | Map

Wednesday 11/8, 1:30 pm - 3:00 pm

A Celebration of Life will be held from 1:30 pm until 3:00 pm, Wednesday, November 8, 2023, at Buck Creek United Methodist Church, 4915 Ferret St., Buck Creek. IN 47924.

Memorial contributions in Jay’s name may be given to the Buck Creek United Methodist Church or to the Buck Creek Volunteer Fire Department.

Send Flowers & Gifts

Jay L. Mitchell, 67, of Buck Creek, passed away at his home on Tuesday, October 31, 2023, with his wife, Karen by his side. He was born January 24, 1956, in Lafayette to the late James E. and E. Marlene (Buck) Mitchell. Jay was a 1974 graduate of William H. Harrison High School. On JuneContinue Reading

See Condolences

What a wonderful man.

I'm so sorry for your loss Karen. Jay was amazing person. I always loved to make him laugh and watch him fly around in the smart car. I'm greatful my family and I were part of the Buck Creek Pizza family. He still has the best pizza combo I've ever had. I always called it the "Jay special"

Always an entertaining time when working with Jay. Many MEMORIES! May you find PEACE in his PEACE! In my thoughts and prayers.

In memory of Jay L. Mitchell, Matt and Donna lit a candle

Jay was one of the nicest guys I’ve met in my life, my condolences to his family

Peace of mind is a call away. We’re here when you need us most.

Our most sincere condolences for your loss Karen.

I very sorry for your loss. My prayers are with you and your family.

Karen, We are so sorry to hear of Jay’s passing. Prayers for God’s peace and comfort at this difficult time. Brett and Ronnette

Karen - so sorry! You probably don't remember me. I raced IMCA cars with Jay at Henery's Speedway. He was a good and fair racer. Jay and I crossed paths many times in the years since then. He always had a great smile and greeting for me. Enjoy the memories - Andy.

I'm so sorry to hear of Jay's passing. You are in my thoughts and prayers during this difficult time.

Karen, keeping you in my thoughts and prayers as you deal with the loss of Jay. You both were such great people!

Karen and family, I am sorry to hear the passing of Jay, LJ sent me the info. I have known the Mitchell family since I was in the 3rd grade. My late father was a volunteer Buck Creek fireman and he the Mitchell family were on the department together. My heart goes out to you and the family. A longtime Buck Creek kid. RIP Jay.

Karen, I am so sorry to hear about this ?? my thoughts and prayers are with you and the others

Karen, Wishing you peace and healing as you mourn the loss of your beloved husband.

Karen - We are so very sorry to hear of Jay's passing. We loved seeing and chatting with him when we ordered Pizza's. Our thoughts are with you during this difficult time. May the fond memories you hold dear provide you peace.

Karen, so so sorry for your loss. You both were the best boss a person could have. Much love sweetheart..

See ya later buddy... Happy you were part of my life for so many years... Will be looking for you when I get there....

Peace of mind is a call away. We’re here when you need us most.

So sorry for your loss Karen. You have my deepest sympathy.

Karen, we were so very sorry to hear the news about Jay's passing. He was a great guy. The two of you were such great people for our son to work for. Please know you will be in our thoughts & prayers.

I very sorry for your loss. Jay was a great co-worker and a good man. I always enjoyed having conversations with Jay at Dayton Station. Rest in peace my friend.

Sorry for your loss. Prayers for the family.

Please accept our deepest condolences for your family's loss.